A Real Pain - Screenplay Analysis
​
Synopsis
​
"A Real Pain" follows David and Benji Kaplan, cousins in their thirties who embark on a Holocaust heritage tour in Poland to honor their recently deceased grandmother, Dory. David is a buttoned-up digital advertising executive from New York with a wife and young son, while Benji is an unemployed, emotionally volatile man living in his mother's basement in Binghamton. The trip was funded by their grandmother's will, and it becomes clear that Benji has recently attempted suicide, which motivated David to finally take this journey with him.
​
As they navigate Warsaw and Lublin with their small tour group, the contrast between the cousins becomes stark. Benji effortlessly charms fellow travelers—including Holocaust survivor-turned-convert Eloge, recently divorced Marcia, and even their British guide James—while David feels increasingly invisible and frustrated. Benji's charismatic yet destructive behavior reaches a breaking point during emotional moments of the tour, particularly when visiting the Majdanek concentration camp.
​
The story culminates with a confrontation on a Lublin rooftop where both men reveal their deepest insecurities: David's exhausting pursuit of normalcy and his envy of Benji's natural magnetism, and Benji's recognition of his self-destructive tendencies. Their final destination—their grandmother's modest former home in Krasnystaw—proves anticlimactic, but the gesture of placing stones on her stoop becomes a moment of connection. The film ends with David returning to his comfortable life while Benji chooses to remain at JFK Airport, suggesting both growth and an uncertain future.
​
Premise and Concept
​
Jesse Eisenberg has crafted a deeply personal exploration of family trauma, survivor's guilt, and the weight of inherited history. I think the central concept is brilliantly conceived—using a Holocaust heritage tour as the backdrop for examining how different people process both historical and personal trauma. The title "A Real Pain" works on multiple levels: Benji's literal emotional pain, David's psychological burden, and the historical pain they're exploring together.
​
What makes this premise particularly strong is how it avoids obvious Holocaust drama tropes. This isn't about the historical atrocities themselves, but rather about how contemporary Jewish Americans grapple with that legacy while dealing with their own modern struggles. The juxtaposition of privilege and suffering, past and present, creates rich thematic material throughout.
​
Opening Twenty Pages
​
Your opening sequence at JFK Airport immediately establishes the dynamic between these cousins while introducing the melancholy tone that will permeate the entire script. I like how you begin with Benji alone on the bench—it's our first hint that isolation is central to his character, even when surrounded by people.
The series of voicemails David leaves while rushing to the airport (pages 1-4) efficiently establishes his anxious, controlling personality while building anticipation for their reunion. When Benji reveals he's been at the airport for hours and bought David a yogurt, you immediately show us his thoughtful yet unpredictable nature. The detail about the warm yogurt that David secretly discards is perfect—it captures both Benji's sweetness and David's inability to accept imperfect gestures.
​
I think the security checkpoint scene is particularly well-crafted. Benji's easy charm with TSA agent Jasmine contrasts beautifully with David's nervous energy about the weed situation. This efficiently shows us how differently they navigate the world—Benji through charisma, David through worry.
​
The airplane sequence effectively deepens their dynamic. Benji's insistence that David take the middle seat, followed by his critique of David's work and then his surprising attention to the flight safety demonstration, establishes his contradictory nature. You're showing us someone who can be both selfish and considerate, critical and respectful, often within the same scene.
​
Structure and Pacing
​
The three-act structure flows naturally, though I'd say this functions more like a character study than a traditional plot-driven narrative. Act One establishes the relationship and gets them to Poland. Act Two explores their dynamic through the tour group interactions and historical sites. Act Three builds to their confrontation and resolution.
I think your use of the tour group as a structural device is smart because it provides external pressure and witnesses to their relationship dynamic. The other tourists—particularly Marcia, Eloge, and James—serve as both Greek chorus and mirror, reflecting back different aspects of the cousins' personalities.
​
The pacing feels authentic to real travel, with moments of boredom, unexpected connections, and gradual revelations. However, I would recommend tightening some of the middle sections, particularly around pages 40-60, where the tour group interactions occasionally feel repetitive. You might consider combining some of the Warsaw sightseeing scenes to maintain momentum.
​
The revelation about Benji's suicide attempt (page 71) lands powerfully because you've built to it gradually rather than using it as a shocking twist. David's confession to the group feels earned and necessary at that point in the story.
​
Character Development
​
David and Benji are beautifully realized as two sides of the same generational coin. David represents the "successful" outcome of immigrant aspiration—educated, employed, married with children—yet he's deeply anxious and feels invisible. Benji embodies the charismatic failure, someone with natural gifts who can't translate them into conventional success.
​
I think David's character arc is particularly strong. You show him gradually recognizing his own limitations and prejudices. His confession scene (pages 70-71) is a breakthrough moment where he admits both his love and frustration with Benji. The rooftop confrontation (pages 83-89) allows him to finally articulate his envy and exhaustion.
​
Benji is more enigmatic, which works for the story. His charm is undeniable, but you never let us forget the darkness underneath. I like that you don't provide easy explanations for his behavior—he's neither purely sympathetic nor unsympathetic. The revelation about his suicide attempt recontextualizes his entire journey without excusing his more problematic moments.
​
The supporting characters serve their purposes well. Marcia provides maternal energy that Benji craves, while Eloge offers intellectual validation. James represents institutional knowledge that Benji instinctively rebels against. I think you could slightly strengthen Diane and Mark's presence, as they sometimes feel like background figures.
​
Dialogue and Voice
​
The dialogue feels remarkably natural throughout. You've given each character a distinct voice—David's anxious precision, Benji's casual profanity mixed with surprising insight, James's earnest expertise, Marcia's sharp wit. I particularly admire how you handle the exposition about their grandmother and family history. It emerges organically through conversation rather than forced backstory dumps.
​
Benji's dialogue is especially well-crafted. Lines like "Rich people are fuckin idiots" and his various observations about privilege ring true to his character while advancing the themes. His ability to say profound things in crude language ("Money's like fuckin heroin for boring people") captures his contradictory nature perfectly.
​
I think David's more reserved speaking style effectively contrasts with Benji's openness. When David finally explodes on the rooftop ("Don't call me fucking 'dude'!"), it carries extra weight because we've seen him suppress his emotions throughout the script.
​
The Polish dialogue and James's tour guide explanations add authenticity without becoming overwhelming. You strike a good balance between historical information and character development.
​
Setting and Atmosphere
​
Poland becomes almost a third character in this story. I think your choice to use real locations like the Warsaw Ghetto Monument and Majdanek concentration camp grounds the story in authentic historical weight. The contrast between the modern, touristy aspects of their journey and the historical gravity of the sites creates productive tension.
​
The hotel scenes effectively establish intimacy and privacy where the cousins can be more honest with each other. I particularly like the rooftop sequences—they provide elevation both literally and metaphorically for key emotional moments.
​
Krasnystaw, their grandmother's hometown, wisely avoids sentimentality. The ordinariness of the house and the practical concern about the stones creates a bittersweet rather than cathartic ending. This feels true to how such pilgrimages often unfold in reality.
​
Thematic Depth
​
The central theme of inherited trauma versus personal pain runs throughout the script. You explore how privilege can create its own form of suffering without diminishing historical atrocities. Benji's question on the train—about whether they should feel guilty for their comfortable lives—drives much of the philosophical tension.
​
I think the theme of visibility versus invisibility is equally important. Benji draws attention effortlessly while David feels overlooked, yet both suffer from their positions. The Holocaust background amplifies this theme—these are people whose ancestors were made invisible through systematic murder, yet their descendants struggle with different forms of being seen or unseen.
​
The exploration of American Jewish identity feels authentic and complex. You avoid both excessive guilt and comfortable detachment, showing characters genuinely grappling with their relationship to this history.
​
Technical Elements
​
Your scene transitions are generally smooth, though I'd recommend tightening some of the montage sequences. The musical cues using Chopin pieces create a sophisticated emotional landscape that enhances the Polish setting while maintaining the melancholy tone.
​
I think the visual writing is strong throughout. Details like David secretly throwing away the yogurt, Benji's "graceful" feet, and the stones in their pockets create memorable images that support the emotional story.
​
The structure of intercutting between their shared experiences and private moments works well. You give us enough alone time with each character to understand their internal worlds while maintaining their relationship as the central focus.
​
Areas for Improvement
​
While the script is largely successful, I would recommend some adjustments. The middle section could be tightened—some of the tour group interactions feel repetitive, particularly in the Warsaw section. You might consider combining some of the sightseeing scenes to maintain momentum.
​
I think James's character could be slightly more complex. While his earnestness works for the story, a bit more personal investment in the tour or subtle reaction to Benji's criticisms might add depth.
​
The ending, while appropriate, might benefit from a slightly stronger sense of David's transformation. We see him place the stone on his own stoop, but perhaps a small moment showing how this experience might change his future behavior could strengthen the resolution.
​
Some of the historical exposition, while necessary, occasionally slows the pace. You might consider integrating some of James's information more naturally into character interactions rather than formal presentations.
​
Conclusion
​
"A Real Pain" is a remarkably mature and nuanced exploration of family relationships, inherited trauma, and contemporary Jewish identity. Jesse Eisenberg has created two complex, contradictory characters whose relationship feels authentic and lived-in. The use of the Holocaust heritage tour as a backdrop is inspired, providing historical weight without exploiting tragedy for dramatic effect.
​
The script's greatest strength lies in its refusal to provide easy answers or clear resolutions. Both David and Benji remain flawed and complicated at the end, which feels true to life. Their relationship is neither healed nor destroyed—it's simply better understood by both of them and the audience.
​
This is the kind of screenplay that trusts its audience to engage with complex emotions and moral ambiguity. It's both deeply personal and universally relevant, exploring how we carry forward the pain of previous generations while dealing with our own contemporary struggles. The writing is confident, the characters are fully realized, and the themes resonate long after reading. This feels like a complete, shootable script that would make a compelling film.